Join the AMA (Ask Me Anything) with the Firefox leadership team to celebrate Firefox 20th anniversary and discuss Firefox’s future on Mozilla Connect. Mark your calendar on Thursday, November 14, 18:00 - 20:00 UTC!

This site will have limited functionality while we undergo maintenance to improve your experience. If an article doesn't solve your issue and you want to ask a question, we have our support community waiting to help you at @FirefoxSupport on Twitter and/r/firefox on Reddit.

Search Support

Avoid support scams. We will never ask you to call or text a phone number or share personal information. Please report suspicious activity using the “Report Abuse” option.

Learn More

Thunderbird locks up (spinning wheel til I terminate the program) on S/MIME encrypted messages

  • 3 odgovori
  • 0 ima ovaj problem
  • 13 views
  • Posljednji odgovor poslao BarnRat1

more options

I regularly receive and send emails with an S/MIME signature on a ECA card (certs are authenticated via the US Government). I also use a Yubikey for MFA, those certs are authenticated by our local certificate server. Several emails per day are encrypted with the certificates on the ECA card, mostly received. I use ActiveClient as the driver for the ECA card. The last few releases of Thunderbird have been particularly problematic in that 1) if the ECA card has not been previously authenticated with a PIN, and I try to send a signed email, the Broadcom card reader does not recognize when the ECA card is inserted, although it does see the Yubikey device, 2) If the ECA has been authenticated within the 10 minute timeout period, Thunderbird will let me send a signed email; 3) after the card has timed out 2-4 times, Thunderbird no longer responds after trying to read an encrypted email even if I authenticate the ECA using ActiveClient or going to a secure website that requires the ECA card for access. Note that FireFox will let me successfully re-authenticate no matter how many times the authentication has timed out.

My current issue is that I cannot get Thunderbird to respond at all, as the last thing I tried to look at was an encrypted email. Every time I restart Thunderbird, it opens on that email and I can't seem to close the tab before it locks up, then gives me the spinning wheel... Attached is a screen shot of task manager where TB is not responding. I will try rebooting next to see if I can get a cleaner start to TB get the version number, and read a couple of emails before it locks up.

I regularly receive and send emails with an S/MIME signature on a ECA card (certs are authenticated via the US Government). I also use a Yubikey for MFA, those certs are authenticated by our local certificate server. Several emails per day are encrypted with the certificates on the ECA card, mostly received. I use ActiveClient as the driver for the ECA card. The last few releases of Thunderbird have been particularly problematic in that 1) if the ECA card has not been previously authenticated with a PIN, and I try to send a signed email, the Broadcom card reader does not recognize when the ECA card is inserted, although it does see the Yubikey device, 2) If the ECA has been authenticated within the 10 minute timeout period, Thunderbird will let me send a signed email; 3) after the card has timed out 2-4 times, Thunderbird no longer responds after trying to read an encrypted email even if I authenticate the ECA using ActiveClient or going to a secure website that requires the ECA card for access. Note that FireFox will let me successfully re-authenticate no matter how many times the authentication has timed out. My current issue is that I cannot get Thunderbird to respond at all, as the last thing I tried to look at was an encrypted email. Every time I restart Thunderbird, it opens on that email and I can't seem to close the tab before it locks up, then gives me the spinning wheel... Attached is a screen shot of task manager where TB is not responding. I will try rebooting next to see if I can get a cleaner start to TB get the version number, and read a couple of emails before it locks up.
Priloženi snimci ekrana

Izabrano rješenje

I have subscribed to the e2ee topicbox, but this issue seems to have been related to a hardware problem with my cardreader, which failed a few weeks after my previous post. I have not experienced these issues since installing the new card reader.

Pročitajte ovaj odgovor sa objašnjenjem 👍 0

All Replies (3)

more options

Additional information: I have rebooted, and upon restarting Thunderbird I was finally quick enough to close the tab that displayed the encrypted email, then moved to another tab for saved files (empty), and closed TB so it would have a stable place to return to. Upon restart it operated normally, I could download and read email. I then made sure the ECA was authenticated, and went to an encrypted email where TB promptly became unresponsive. So it appears I cannot access the encrypted email at all (I was able to view it once), but it appears I can no longer access it using the sequence that previously worked for me. TB is version 102.3.3, 64 bit. Any help in getting TB to work in a stable fashion with ECA S/MIME certs would be greatly appreciated!

more options

You may want to join the Thunderbird e2ee mailing list on Topicbox and post your problem there. https://thunderbird.topicbox.com/groups/e2ee

more options

Odabrano rješenje

I have subscribed to the e2ee topicbox, but this issue seems to have been related to a hardware problem with my cardreader, which failed a few weeks after my previous post. I have not experienced these issues since installing the new card reader.