This site will have limited functionality while we undergo maintenance to improve your experience. If an article doesn't solve your issue and you want to ask a question, we have our support community waiting to help you at @FirefoxSupport on Twitter and/r/firefox on Reddit.

Search Support

Avoid support scams. We will never ask you to call or text a phone number or share personal information. Please report suspicious activity using the “Report Abuse” option.

Learn More

Natao arisiva ity resaka mitohy ity. Mametraha fanontaniana azafady raha mila fanampiana.

How do you determine which device will be synced with what?

  • 5 valiny
  • 2 manana an'ity olana ity
  • 24 views
  • Valiny farany nomen'i John99

more options

I have multiple computers, and I don't know which one is providing the "base" sync, or which one is being upgraded. It appears that new changes (an added extension, or bookmark) gets "erased" by something. There does not seem to be a way to say PC 'A' is the device to sync to or, to say PC 'B' adds a bookmark and I want it reflected on 'A' and 'C.'

It would help if I could access or see the sync so that I could figure what is forming the "base" of my synced data, or if I could edit that directly to push to all devices.

I have multiple computers, and I don't know which one is providing the "base" sync, or which one is being upgraded. It appears that new changes (an added extension, or bookmark) gets "erased" by something. There does not seem to be a way to say PC 'A' is the device to sync to or, to say PC 'B' adds a bookmark and I want it reflected on 'A' and 'C.' It would help if I could access or see the sync so that I could figure what is forming the "base" of my synced data, or if I could edit that directly to push to all devices.

All Replies (5)

more options

You don't !

Firefox sync uses a server but basically all it does is make whatever you choose the same on all devices. Sync is not directional. Sync should add things but not delete them.

Please also take care with bookmarks. If you sync bookmarks it may be good practice to make manual backups. Sync may in some circumstances corrupt or duplicate bookmarks, having a manual backup can make it easier to dig yourself out of the resultant mess.

more options

I'm not sure it is actually working that way. I had synced a computer that had my current (at that point) complement of add-ons and settings. Then I worked on my other computer (that was not current). When I went back to computer A, it had "lost" several of the plugins, and most of the settings. It was as if Sync had reverse synced computer A to Computer B's settings rather than from A to B. Hence, it seems that rather than simply duplicating (or adding on) information, sync replaced information.

more options

Hi rowan, Well Sync is not supposed to remove things.

Possibly there is some other explanation. Addons or Plugins just becoming incompatible for instance. If you find you are able to recreate that sort of issue please explain how, as maybe then it would be appropriate to file a bug.

I am not aware whether Sync has any checks to prevent corruption whereby it could overwrite and remove settings. Maybe someone who has a deeper understanding of Sync will chime in. I know it can corrupt bookmarks but that tends to result in additions not deletions. I probably would not be surprised to learn it may also delete or lose data

  • See Bug 621584 - [meta] Bookmarks dataloss (duplicated, reordered, moved, lost, attributes changed, etc) caused by Sync
  • Please note etiquette

I get the impression Sync is something that is convenient, but not terribly robust, and that it could require major work to improve Sync

Of course if you can reproduce the issue it will be easier to investigate. Maybe set up a couple of new instances of Firefox with their own profiles on one of your computers. Set out with them different and create a new Sync (For obvious reasons do not use the current Sync) just Sync the two new Firefox installs.

(Of course this may even be a known issue there are a lot of Sync related bugs filed a quick search on sync loss lists 4 bugs and two of those are tracking or meta bugs )

I will add an escalate tag to this. Let's see if one of the professional help desk staff is able to add to this. (If they reply it could take three days to a week - please bump the thread next week if no one else chimes in).


P.S. I have also added tags

  • syncdata | issues with dataloss
  • sync+addons {so addons addon tag added}| Support thread relates to an issue with the addons collections

You maybe interested in glancing at

(I am not sure if anyone is tagging threads !?) Modified February 24, 2016 at 3:54:02 PM GMT by John99


2nd edit tagged addon not addons I am trying to clarify Helpdesk's {Rachel) request to tag questions

Novain'i John99 t@

more options

Thanks John. I appreciate your sharing your knowledge and your suggestions. I will try setting up some different installs and a test account and play around with it to see what happens. May take me a few days though as I am kind of buried with work at the moment.

more options

I am not sure we will really be able to resolve this issue properly. I suspect the most we will be able to do is identify it as being a known bug or add to the existing list of bugs.

On the other hand it is possible you have found some so far unknown recent regression and that will need fixing quickly.