This site will have limited functionality while we undergo maintenance to improve your experience. If an article doesn't solve your issue and you want to ask a question, we have our support community waiting to help you at @FirefoxSupport on Twitter and/r/firefox on Reddit.

Avatar for Username

Search Support

Avoid support scams. We will never ask you to call or text a phone number or share personal information. Please report suspicious activity using the “Report Abuse” option.

Learn More

Natao arisiva ity resaka mitohy ity. Mametraha fanontaniana azafady raha mila fanampiana.

Filters only work for a few messages

  • 3 valiny
  • 1 manana an'ity olana ity
  • 3 views
  • Valiny farany nomen'i christ1

abraunsdorf
abraunsdorf
more options

I have many filters set up in Thunderbird, and they're great when they work, but I cannot run (at least some of them) on entire folders or "large" numbers of messages. I'm not sure what the limit is, but it'll do a few hundred and not a few thousand. If I select a message or a few dozen, it works. If I select, say, 2000 messages, and tell it to run filters on selected messages, it just doesn't do it, or starts to do it (shows the progress indicator) but stops before it's done and doesn't move anything. Additionally, once I exceed this limit, filters don't seem to work at all until I restart Thunderbird.

The main filter I know of that has this problem (which has been a great problem for me) is one to move old mail from one box to a local folder. It selects on addressee and age in days. It works fine if I do a message or two, or in very small batches, but not en masse. If there's one thing computers are good at, it's en masse, so this is frustrating.

I have many filters set up in Thunderbird, and they're great when they work, but I cannot run (at least some of them) on entire folders or "large" numbers of messages. I'm not sure what the limit is, but it'll do a few hundred and not a few thousand. If I select a message or a few dozen, it works. If I select, say, 2000 messages, and tell it to run filters on selected messages, it just doesn't do it, or starts to do it (shows the progress indicator) but stops before it's done and doesn't move anything. Additionally, once I exceed this limit, filters don't seem to work at all until I restart Thunderbird. The main filter I know of that has this problem (which has been a great problem for me) is one to move old mail from one box to a local folder. It selects on addressee and age in days. It works fine if I do a message or two, or in very small batches, but not en masse. If there's one thing computers are good at, it's en masse, so this is frustrating.

All Replies (3)

christ1
christ1
  • Top 25 Contributor
more options

Mail servers aren't made for mass transactions. So I'd rather suspect the problem on the server than with Thunderbird. Presumably you'd see the same behavior if you'd do the mass move transaction manually, without any filter involvement.

abraunsdorf
abraunsdorf Tompon'ny fanontaniana
more options

You're right- I'd forgotten I'd tried that (this is an old problem causing me new pain). It's the moving (specifically the downloading, it seems) that's the problem.

I'll reiterate though, why can't Thunderbird insulate me from this problem by doing whatever it has to move mail en masse? I don't care how long it takes or if it has to do them internally in very small batches. I can do it in small batches from the GUI, so it could do it too.

Making me, a human, do things over and over instead of software doing it is madness- that's what we invented computers for- and the point of a user-level application like Thunderbird is to protect users from technical details.

christ1
christ1
  • Top 25 Contributor
more options

Feel free to raise an enhancement bug. https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/