This site will have limited functionality while we undergo maintenance to improve your experience. If an article doesn't solve your issue and you want to ask a question, we have our support community waiting to help you at @FirefoxSupport on Twitter and/r/firefox on Reddit.

Search Support

Avoid support scams. We will never ask you to call or text a phone number or share personal information. Please report suspicious activity using the “Report Abuse” option.

Learn More

Save attachments that all have the same name - Thunderbird wants to overwrite

  • 5 replies
  • 0 have this problem
  • 1 view
  • Last reply by Stans

more options

Hello, I have a few emails in Thunderbird with 50 attachments each and I want to save those attachments locally. However all attachments do have exactly the same name, thus when I click "Save all" then Thunderbird will ask me 49 times if I want to replace the existing file.

I asked the sender if he can create different names but he says it's impossible with the mailer he is using (which is Gmail. I am not using Gmail.)

What can I do? I need the those files locally to further process them.

Hello, I have a few emails in Thunderbird with 50 attachments each and I want to save those attachments locally. However all attachments do have exactly the same name, thus when I click "Save all" then Thunderbird will ask me 49 times if I want to replace the existing file. I asked the sender if he can create different names but he says it's impossible with the mailer he is using (which is Gmail. I am not using Gmail.) What can I do? I need the those files locally to further process them.

All Replies (5)

more options

The sender could rename the files before attaching them. I don't see how Gmail has anything to do with this.

No matter, you could change Thunderbird's settings so that it always asks where to save the attachments. That option is in Settings > Files & Attachments. When you select Save all, it will ask for a location to save those files. You will then be able to choose a different location for each message that you want to save the attachments from. For example; Message 1 with 50 attachments saved in Folder 1, Message 2's attachments in Folder 2 etc. I am assuming that the attachments in any given message have unique names.

more options

No, they do not have unique names. All 50 attachments in each mail have the same file name, that's the problem which Thunderbird can't handle by itself (like automatically adding numbers to the file names).

Interesting, Thunderbird handles the same problem very well when I save multiple emails to files ("save as…") and it happens that 2 or more mails have the exact same subject and time (which the file name is made of), then the second file will have "-2" at the end of the filename before the dot, the third "-3" and so on.

The reason why those attachments that I received have the same name and why the sender can't just change them is secondary. The attachments are emails forwarded as attachments, which all have the same subject thus the same file name.

more options

The inbuilt Save as facility is not available for saving multiple attachments, unlike saving multiple messages to files. The Save all facility for attachments lacks the auto-increment-numbering that the Save as facility offers. You could share that idea here https://connect.mozilla.org. Alternatively, the ImportExportTools NG add-on seems to support extended naming options for both messages and attachments. Let me know what version of Thunderbird you're running.

more options

Hello Stans, thanks for the idea. I am currently using Thunderbird 102.13.0 (I decided to wait for the brand new Thunderbird to be available in Ubuntu repositories).

EDIT: I tried to do something with ImportExportTools NG but I can not find a way to save single emails and attachments with it. Export the whole folder and then find the attachments?

Modified by gregor12

more options

I'm not sure if the Thunderbird-102-compatible version of ImportExportTools NG has this facility, so you'll have to check as follows:

1. Open Thunderbird's menu and go to Add-ons and Themes. Click the wrench (spanner) icon next to ImportExportTools NG to open its options dialog.

2. Switch to the Filenames tab.

3. Under the Attachment Folder Names section, right next to the Attachment Folders field, do you see a white question mark circled in orange?

Modified by Stans